1995

Nominee

Best Actor in a Leading Role
Mr. Holland’s Opus

1977

Winner

Best Actor in a Leading Role
The Goodbye Girl

1978

Winner

Best Leading Actor
The Goodbye Girl

1975

Nominee

Best Leading Actor
Jaws

1995

Nominee

Best Actor – Drama
Mr. Holland’s Opus

1987

Nominee

Best Actor in a Supporting Role
Nuts

1977

Winner

Best Actor – Musical or Comedy
The Goodbye Girl

1973

Nominee

Best Actor – Musical or Comedy
American Graffiti